La paridad del poder de compra - Una revisión crítica


  • Mario Gómez Aguirre Instituto de Investigaciones Económicas y Empresariales


Palabras clave:

paridad del poder de compra, precios, tipo de cambio, cambio estructural


En este artículo se hace una revisión de la literatura sobre la paridad del poder decompra (PPC) internacional. Una de las posibles explicaciones del no cumplimientode la PPC es el efecto Harrod-Balassa-Samuelson y la presencia de cambiosestructurales en las economías, que se reflejan en las variables económicas como eltipo de cambio real. Los resultados de la revisión de la literatura revelan que se hamejorado los resultados a favor de la PPC, utilizando los avances econométricoscon la metodología de datos panel y la incorporación de cambios estructurales. Sinembrago, los resultados aún siguen siendo no concluyentes.

Biografía del autor/a

Mario Gómez Aguirre, Instituto de Investigaciones Económicas y Empresariales

Profesor Investigador del Instituto de Investigaciones Económicas y Empresariales de la Universidad Michoacanade San Nicolás de Hidalgo


Abuaf, N., y P. Jorion (1990), “Purchasing Power Parity in the Long Run”, Journalof Finance, 45, 1, 104, 488-509.Alba, J. y D. Papell (2005), “Purchasing Power Parity and Country Characteristics:Evidence from Panel Data Tests” Department of Economics, UniversityHouston, www.uh.ed/~dpapell/char.pdf.Arne, K., (2005), “Fundamentals of Real Exchange Rate Determination: WhatRole in the Peso Crisis?”, Estudios Económicos, 21, 1, 3-22.Ávalos, A., y F. Hernández (1995), “Comportamiento del Tipo de Cambio Real yDesempeño Económico en México”, Economía Mexicana. Nueva Época,2, 239-263.Balassa, B. (1964), “The Purchasing-Power Parity Doctrine: A Reappraisal”, Journalof Political Economy, 72, 584-596.Basher, S., y Carrion-i-Silvestre (2007), “Another look at the Null of StationaryReal Exchange Rates: Panel Data with Structural Breaks and Cross-sectionDependence”,, S., y M. Mohsin (2004), “PPP Tests in Cointegrated Panels: Evidence fromAsian Developing Countries” Applied Economics Letters, 11, 163-166.Canzoneri, Matthew B., Robert E. Cumby, y Behzand Diba, (1999), “RelativeLabor Productivity and the Real Exchange Rate in the Long Run: Evidencefor a Panel of OECD Countries”, Journal of International Economics, 47,245-66.Carlsson, M., J. Lyhagen, P. Österholm (2007), “Testing for Purchasing PowerParity in Cointegrated Panels”, IMF Working Paper No. 287.Cassel, G. (1916), “The Present Situation of the Foreign Exchanges”, EconomicJournal, 26, 101, 62-65._____ (1918), “Abnormal Deviations in International Exchanges” Economic Journal,28, 112, 413-15._____ (1919), “The Depreciation of the German Mark”, Economic Journal, 29,116, 492-96.

_____ (1921), The Word’s Monetary Problem (New York)._____ (1922), Money and Foreign Exchange after 1914 (New York)._____ (1925), “Rates of Exchange and Purchasing Power Parity,” SkandinaviskaKreditaktiebolaget, Quarterly Report, 29, 17-21._____ (1928), “Post-War Monetary Stabilization”, OPTICA Report 1976.Cerrato, M., y N. Sarantis (2007), “Does Purchasing Power Parity Hold in EmergingMarkets? Evidence from a Panel of Black Market Exchange Rates”,International Journal of Finance and Economics, 12, 427-444.Cheung, Y.-W., and K.S. Lai (1994), “Mean Reversion in Real Exchange Rates,”Economics Letters, 46, 251-56.Chinn, M., (2000), “The Usual Suspects? Productivity and Demand Shocks andAsia-Pacific real Exchange Rates”, Review of International Economics, 8,20-43.Darné, O., y J-F Hoarau (2008), “The Purchasing Power Parity in Australia:Evidence from Unit Root Test with Structural Break”, Applied EconomicsLetters, 15, 203-206.Doganlar, M. H. Bal y M. Özmen (2008), “ Testing Lon-Run Validity of PurchasingPower Pariy for Selected Emerging Market Economies”, Applied EconomicsLetters, 1-6._____(2009), “Testing Long Run Validity of Purchasing Power Parity for SelectedEmerging Market Economies? Applied Economics Letters, 1-6.Dornbusch, R. (1987), “Exchange Rate Economics: 1986,” National Bureau ofEconomic Research, Working Paper No. 2071._____ (1987), “Purchasing Power Parity” in The new Palgrave dictionary of economics.Eds: JOHN EATWELL, MURRAY MILGATE, AND PETERNEWMAN. London: MacMillan; New York: Stockton Press._____ (1988), Purchasing Power Parity, in Exchange Rates and Inflation, Cambridge,Mass., The MIT Press.Edwards, S. (1989), “Exchange Rate Misalignment in Developing Countries,”Research Observer, 4, 1, The World Bank, January.Frait, J. (2008), “The Real Exchange Rate Misaligment in the Five Central EuropeanCountries-Single Equation Approach”, en P. Karadeloglou y Terraza V.(eds.), Exchange Rates and Macroeconomic Dybamics, Palgrave Macmillan,Nueva York

Frenkel, J. (1981), “The Collapse of Purchasing Power Parities in the 1970s,”European Economic Review, 16, 145-165.Gabás et al. (2005), “Breaks, Co-Breaks and Real Exchange Rates” Trabajo deinvestigación,, L. M. (1995), “Una Nota sobre el Tipo de Cambio en México”,Investigación Económica, 212, abril-junio, 113-134.Galindo, L. M. y H. Catalán (2003), “The PPP hypothesis and the Mexican real.Exchange rate: a long term perspective”, Applied Economics Letters.Harberger, A. C. (2003). “Economic Growth and Real Exchange Rate: Revisitingthe Balassa-Samuelson Effect”, Paper prepared for the Conference organizedby The Higher School of Economics, Moscow, April.Harrod, R. (1933), International Economics, Londres: Nisbet y Cambridge UniversityPress.Im, K., J. Lee y M. Tieslau (2005), “Panel LM Unit Root Tests with Level Shifts”,Oxford Bulletin of Economics an Statistics, 67, 0305-9049.Isard, P. (1995), Exchange Rate Economics, Cambridge Surveys of EconomicLiterature, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Jacobson, T., J. Lyhagen, R. Larsson y M. Nessén (2008), “Inflation, Exchangerates and PPP in a Multivariate Panel Cointegration Model”, EconometricsJournal, 11, 1-22.Kalyoncu, H. y K. Kalyoncu (2008), “Purchasing Power Parity in OECD Countries:Evidence from Panel Unit Root”, Economic Modelling, 25, 440-445._____ (2007), “Purchasing Power Parity in OECD Countries: Evidence from PanelUnit Root”, Economic Modelling, 1-6.Kalyoncu, K., (2009), “New Evidence of the Validity of Purchasing Power Parityfrom Turkey”, Applied Economics Letters, 16, 63-67.Koukouritakis (2009), “Testing the Purchasing Power Parity: Evidence from theNew EU Countries”, Applied Economics Letters, 16, 39-44.Lau, C. K. M. (2009), “A More Power Panel Unit Root test with an Application toPPP”, Applied Economics Letters, 16, 75-80.Lee, J., y M. Keung (2006), “Does Productivity Growth Appreciate the RealExchange Rate?”, Journal of International Economics, 14, 1-21.

Levitch, R. M. (1985), “Empirical studies of exchange rates: price behaviour, ratedetermination and market efficiency,” in Handbook of InternationalEconomics, edited by R. W. Jones and P. B. Kenen, Amsterdam, NorthHolland, Vol. II, Ch.19.Liew, V. K. S., Lee, H. A. y Lim, KP (2009), “Purchasing Power Parity in AsianEconomies: Further Evidence from Ranks Tests for Cointegration”, AppliedEconomics Letters, 16, 51-54.Lothian, J., y M. Taylor (1996), “Real Exchange Rate Behavior: The Recent Floatfrom the Perspective of the Past Two Centuries”, Journal of Political Economy,104, 3._____ (2003), “The Harrod-Samuelson Effect and Non-Linear Real ExchangeRate Adjusment”, mimeo, University of Warwick.MacDonald, (2008), “Three Exchange Rate Puzzles: Facto or Fiction?”, en P.Karadeloglou y Terraza V. (eds.), Exchange Rates and MacroeconomicDybamics, Palgrave Macmillan, Nueva York.MacDonald, R., y Ricci, L. A. (2005), “The Real Exchange Rate end the Balassa-Samuelson Effect: The Role of the Distribution Sector”, Pacific EconomicReview, 10, 1, 29-48.Maddala, G. S. y In-Moo Kim (1998), Unit Root, Cointegration and StructuralChange. Cambrige University Press.Mehrara, M. (2007), “Testing the purchasing Power Parity in Oil-ExportingCountries”, OPEC Review, 31, 249-260.Mejía, P., y J. C. González (1996), “La Paridad del Poder de Compra en el LargoPlazo: El Caso de México”, Economía Mexicana. Nueva Época, 1, 37-62.Narayan, P.K. (2006), “The Purchasing Power Parity Revisited: New Evidence for16 OECD Countries from Panel Unit Root Tests with Structural Breaks”,Int. Fin. Markets, Inst. And Money, 1-10._____(2006). “Are Bilateral Real Exchange Rates Stationary? Evidence fromLagrange Multiplier Unit Root Tests for India”, Applied Economics, 38,63-70._____ (2008), “The Purchasing Power Parity Revisited: New Evidence for 16 OECDCountries from Panel Unit Root Tests with Structural Breaks”, Int. Fin.Markets, Inst. and Money, 18, 137-146.

Narayan, P., S. Narayan y P. Prasad (2009), “Evidence on PPP from a CointegrationTest with Multiple Structural Breaks”, Applied Economics Letters, 16, 5-8.Nenna, M. (2001), “Price Level Convergence among Italian Cities: Any Role forthe Harrod –Balassa-Samuelson Hypothesis?”, Working Paper,, A., y L. Medina (2003), “Quasi Purchasing Power Parity: Structural Changein the Mexican Peso/US Dollar Real Exchange Rate”. EstudiosEconómicos, 2,227-236.Officer, L. (1974), “Purchasing Power Parity and Factor Price Equalization,” Kyklos,27, 4, 868-78._____ (1976), “The Purchasing Power Parity Theory of Exchange Rates: A ReviewArticle,” International Monetary Fund, Staff Papers, XXIII, 1._____ (1980), “Effective Exchange Rates and Price Ratios Over the Long Run: ATest of the Purchasing-Power-Parity Theory,” Canadian Journal ofEconomics, XIII, 2._____ (1981), “The Floating Dollar in the Greenback Period: A Test of Theoriesof Exchange-Rate Determination”, The Journal of Economic History, 41, 3,629-650.Papell, D. (2004), “The Panel Purchasing Power Parity Puzzle”, Working Papers,Department of Economics, University of Houston.Roggoff, K. (1996), “The Purchasing Power Parity Puzzle”, Journal of EconomicLiterature, 34, 2, 647-668.Ruiz, P. (2004), “The Purchasing Power Parity Theory and Ricardo’s Theory ofValue” Contributions to Political Economy, 23, 65-80.Sabaté, M., M. D. Gadea y J. M. Serrano (2003), “PPP and Structural Breaks. ThePeseta-Sterling Rate, 50 Years of a Floating Regime”, Journal of InternationalMoney and Finance, 22, 613-627.Salim, R., y K. Hassan (2009), “Does the Relative Population Growth AffectPurchasing Power Parity? Applied Economics Letters, 16, 103-107.Samuelson, P. (1964),”Theorical Notes on Trade Problems”, Review of Economicsand Statistics, 46, 145-54.Schnal, G. (2001), “Purchasing Power Parity: Yen/Dollar Exchange Rate”, The WorldEconomy, 24, 1, 31-50.

Taylor, M. (2002), “A Century of Purchasing Power Parity”, Review of Economics,and Statistics, 84, 139-150._____(2003), “Purchasing Power Parity”, Review of International Economics, 11, 3,436-452._____ (2005), “Real Exchange Rates and Nonlinearities”, en Poul De Grauwe,Exchange Rate Economics: Where Do We Stand?, The MIT Press, London,England.Taylor, M. P., y L. Sarno (1998), “The Behavior of Real Exchange Rate During thePost-Bretton Woods Period “, Journal International Economics, 46, 281-312.Taylor, A., y M., Taylor, (2004), “The Purchasing Power Parity Debate” , Journalof Economic Perspectives, 4, 135-158.Thomas, A., y A. King (2008), “The Balassa-Samuelson Hipótesis in Asia-PacificoRegion Revisited”, Review of International Economics, 16, 1, 127-141.Westerlund, J., y D. Edgerton (2008), “A Simple Test for Cointegration inDependent Panels with Structural Breaks”, Oxford Bulletin of Economicsand Statistics, 70, 665-704.Zhang, S., y T. Lowinger (2006), “An Empirical Test of Purchasing Power Parity inSelected Developing Countries: a Panel Data Approach”, InternationalEconomic Journal, 20, 79-86.